Labour-run Ealing Council has rejected an opposition motion calling for plans for a 1,200-seat temporary Troubadour theatre in Walpole Park to be dropped, with campaigners saying they are now “more fired up than ever” to defeat the proposal.
The motion was led by Liberal Democrat Councillor Connie Hersch, the party’s culture, sports and communities spokesperson, at a full council meeting on Tuesday (13 October 2026).
Labour councillors voted against the motion after Liberal Democrat, Conservative and Green councillors raised objections to the proposed Troubadour theatre, including its impact on the park, the future of summer festivals and the financial risks involved.
Members of the Save Walpole Park campaign attended the meeting, while others watched online.
Save Walpole Park campaigner Marc Goodchild said: “Those of us in the room and who watched the meeting remotely are now more fired up than ever to defeat this unsolicited, untested, back-of-a-fag-packet proposal.”
The council’s cabinet agreed in principle on 9 September 2026 to explore bringing the temporary theatre to Walpole Park for three years, with additional time needed to build and dismantle the structure.
Councillor Hersch told the meeting she supported bringing a major theatre to Ealing but opposed using Walpole Park. If the aim was to establish whether the borough could sustain a permanent theatre, she asked why the council was not considering a location where a permanent venue could eventually be built.
She also highlighted concerns about the future of Walpole Park’s long-running summer festivals. Moving them elsewhere could mean losing audiences built up over many years, as well as creating additional costs and logistical difficulties for organisers.
Councillor Hersch questioned how much extra trade nearby shops, restaurants and bars could expect if theatre audiences were able to eat and drink inside the venue. She also asked who would pay to remove the building if Troubadour ran into financial difficulties.
Ealing Conservative leader Councillor Julian Gallant proposed an amendment seeking a firm commitment that the theatre would be removed at the end of its three-year run.
Councillor Gallant said: “Three years can easily morph into an eternity.”
He told the meeting that more than 8,000 signatures had been collected across petitions opposing the plans and asked where the demand for the theatre had come from.
Drawing on his experience in the theatre industry, Councillor Gallant warned that even West End productions could fail. He questioned whether a 1,200-seat venue in Walpole Park could attract enough audiences for eight performances a week and raised concerns about what would happen if the operator went out of business.
He also spoke about residents living in flats around Ealing Broadway who rely on Walpole Park for outdoor space, and questioned the impact of construction work, generators and cabling on the park.
Ealing Council cabinet member for thriving communities Councillor Lauren Wall opposed the motion and Conservative amendment, arguing that the council should examine the Troubadour theatre proposal before deciding whether it should proceed.
Councillor Wall said: “The opposition are not seeking answers. They are demanding we abandon the process before it’s even started.”
She said questions about wildlife, traffic, noise, heritage and access should be examined through consultation and planning.
Responding to calls for another location, Councillor Wall said: “We own no other site here capable of hosting this venue. Nor are we aware of any suitable brownfield site in private ownership.”
In correspondence with campaigners earlier this month, she confirmed that Troubadour had carried out the review of alternative locations, rather than the council commissioning its own assessment.
Councillor Wall also disputed opposition claims about how much of Walpole Park would be affected.
She said: “They claim a third of the park will be lost. In fact, it’s less than 10% that’s under consideration, meaning over 90% would remain fully accessible.”
She argued that the theatre could bring more visitors to Ealing, increase trade for local businesses and allow residents to see major productions without travelling into central London.
Ealing Council leader Councillor Peter Mason defended the proposal, saying the borough needed to attract more visitors and support town centre businesses affected by changes in shopping habits.
Councillor Mason said: “Now, we have been shown a proposal and that’s exactly what it is, a proposal. It isn’t perfect, but what it is is temporary.”
He said a temporary theatre would help establish whether Ealing could attract enough audiences to support a permanent venue.
Councillor Mason said: “Before a theatre company is going to invest the tens of millions of pounds that would be required to build a state-of-the-art modern theatre that’s capable of hosting West End shows, they will need to understand whether a community like Ealing can sustain it for the long term.”
He also said the temporary building would be removed whether the venture succeeded or failed.
Councillor Mason said: “If it fails, it goes. If it succeeds, it goes. If we don’t achieve terms with the theatre provider, it won’t happen. If it fails planning, it will not happen.”
On consultation, he added: “We want a consultation because we want to test that opinion with the public and we want everybody to take part in that discussion.”
Following the meeting, Marc Goodchild criticised the council’s claims about the theatre’s economic benefits.
He said: “They claim they have a duty to test this concept but show no desire to test the basic economic claim that it will boost the high street.”
Save Walpole Park campaigner Beth Gregory said: “We are now more determined than ever to fight this proposal all the way.”
Campaigner Julie McQueen said opponents would challenge the development through the planning process and could consider legal action.
Save Walpole Park is calling for further documents relating to Troubadour’s proposal to be released, along with independent scrutiny of the expected economic benefits and potential costs.
The campaign’s petition had attracted 5,250 signatures by 4 October, exceeding the 3,671 required to seek a full council debate, subject to verification.
Campaigners are seeking an extraordinary council meeting or confirmation that the petition will be debated in December.
The theatre proposal still requires public consultation, planning permission and a further decision by Ealing Council’s cabinet before it can proceed.


