Campaigners fighting for the future of Ealing’s Victoria Hall have questioned why a committee overseeing the historic building met behind closed doors last week (12 November 2026) with only two of its five independent members present.
Built in 1888 to commemorate Queen Victoria’s Golden Jubilee, Victoria Hall was funded by donations from local people and hosted community events for more than a century. It has been closed for more than three years, as a long-running dispute over its future continues.
The Friends of Victoria Hall (FoVH) say members of the public, including two of their representatives, were asked to leave the Victoria Hall Trust Advisory Committee meeting on 12 November 2026, while their request to address the committee was refused.
According to the group, four senior Ealing Council officers and three councillors attended the meeting, alongside just two independent committee members.
FoVH argues that the arrangements undermine requirements established by the Charity Commission for the committee to operate openly and with a majority of independent members.
In a statement, the group said: “These requirements are being ignored and the process is being driven by Council officers rather than an advisory committee with a majority of independent members.”
However, Ealing Council has rejected suggestions that the meeting was improperly conducted, saying the committee had sufficient members to make decisions and that confidential discussions were necessary to protect the charity’s interests.
The dispute comes a year after a court ruling in November 2025 concerning the council’s plans to lease Victoria Hall to a hotel developer.
According to FoVH, the court ruled that the 2019 lease must be renegotiated by the Trust Advisory Committee in the interests of the charitable trust rather than the council.
The group says this includes establishing which parts of the Ealing Town Hall complex belong to the council and which are owned by the trust.
FoVH says it was prevented from raising the issue at the November meeting, which was closed to the public under a legal exemption. The group says the previous committee meeting in December 2025 was also held behind closed doors.
It has now complained to Ealing Council’s monitoring officer, challenging the decision to exclude the public and questioning whether the legal exemption was correctly applied.
FoVH said: “The Council’s completely unnecessary secrecy is causing yet further delay in determining the Hall’s future and continues to deprive the people of Ealing – the beneficiaries of the gift – of its much-value facilities.”
An Ealing Council spokesperson told EALING.NEWS: “The Victoria Hall Trust Advisory Committee met on 12 November and conducted its business in accordance with the governance arrangements established by the Charity Commission Scheme. The committee had enough members to make official decisions, as confirmed by the chair, and in line with the requirements of the scheme.”
Explaining why the public was excluded, the spokesperson said: “The committee considered it appropriate to meet in exempt session because implementation of the scheme increasingly involves commercially sensitive matters, legal advice and issues affecting the charity’s financial interests.”
The council said the committee had a responsibility to act independently in the charity’s best interests and did not believe sensitive negotiations should take place in public.
The spokesperson added: “The committee rejects suggestions that consideration of matters in exempt session is intended to avoid scrutiny.”
According to the council, the Charity Commission remains actively involved in monitoring implementation of the scheme, while further committee meetings are being arranged to allow fuller attendance and representation.
FoVH says it will continue calling for greater transparency and wants an opportunity to make representations when all five independent members are present.


